Alignment Defined & Problems
Dungeons & Dragons, Pathfinder and other RPGs define Alignment as a character’s or creature’s basic moral and ethical orientation or attitude. Some game systems avoid alignment altogether. In simplistic terms, Alignment has to do with good and evil. However, life isn’t simple. We can all say we have seen “good” people do bad things and have witnessed moments of goodness from “evil” people. Only the brave and the honest can say “I’m a good person, but I’ve done some bad things” or “I’m a bad person, but I’ve done some good.” Just a quick aside – bad people aren’t the only ones in need of redemption.
WHAT (Warrior Heroes Adventures in Talomir) also has an Alignment system. And like all Alignment systems it is flawed in some respects. The section on Alignment begins by saying the “majority” of characters and creatures view their world in absolutes – good and evil. Those that are traditionally good follow the Red Sun and those thought of as traditionally evil follow the Black Moon. There is a third option, those who walk a fine line between good and evil have a neutral or Twilight Alignment.
For ease of play the populations of entire nations are given a predominant Alignment of Red Sun or Black Moon. Unfortunately, this system carries a bias – the Black Moon nations are all based on civilizations that were African, Asian or Middle Eastern – there isn’t a single nation of white folk that follow the Black Moon. It is an ancient stereotype that often gets buried and repeated in our psyche – that which is different must somehow be evil.
Then again, when looking at the ancient and medieval world, even a fantasy one, what is “good” and what is “evil”? Based on their historical equivalencies, all of Talomir practices slavery, including forced slavery due to conquest, economic slavery due to debt, indentured servitude and serfdom (the only form of slavery missing is minimum wage jobs).
Red Sun, Black Moon, & Twilight Interaction
My Black Moon aligned sorceress enters a crowded tavern in a Carousing Encounter and is seated next to a Red Sun apothecary, what happens?
The rules say that Black Moon and Red Sun aligned characters are hostile to each other and will attack when given the “chance.” “Chance” is the key word which gives the Game Master some control. Why doesn’t the sorceress and apothecary immediately pull knives and attack? Well, they could, but what kind of story is that?
It is easy to see that in the wilderness or on the battlefield, the two Alignments would immediately attack one another. But in a tavern, the characters may not know their respective Alignments. And if they did, do they have the “chance” to attack? The sorceress might not attack because she knows she’s in a Red Sun city that is rather fond of burning witches if caught. The apothecary might not attack because he knows there’s laws against fighting and killing. He might get off since she is a sorceress, but what if the local magistrate doesn’t like him or enforces the law regardless of Alignment? It would be a risky gamble.
You as the Game Master can decide outright or use a Challenge to decide when hostile Alignments have the “chance” to attack one another. This allows your Dwarven cook to grudgingly work with a Goblin scullery maid.
If you’ve played Dungeons and Dragons, or other RPGs, you are probably aware of skill checks – Intelligence Checks, Dexterity Checks, Charisma Checks – there are ten or twelve of them depending on the game. Well, WHAT has them too, they’re called Challenges – People Skill Challenges, Savvy Skill Challenges and then there’s Interaction and Intimidation based on Reputation.
I guess the whole purpose of this post is to say that there are situations and encounters in WHAT, just like the real world and other RPGs, where folk of different Alignments have to get along for the most part because of laws or mutual benefit. These kinds of situations are ideal for the Challenge mechanism and Interaction table.
If you aren’t using Challenges in your games, you’re missing a part of the story your character has to tell.
I mean look at your own life, or my life – here I am a sweet kind floozy living in a community full of zombie Republicans!
What are your thoughts on Alignment in role playing games? Is it strictly black versus white? Let me know in the comments.
If you enjoy the content of Atomic Floozy Adventures, please consider making a small donation to help with the costs of maintaining a blog.
Choose an amount
Or enter a custom amount
Your contribution is appreciated.Donate
Or if you prefer using PayPal:
WHAT – A Look at Alignment
If you enjoyed the content of this post, please consider making a small donation to help maintain the blog. Thanks!